球磨机中钨矿石瓷球和钢球磨矿动力学对比研究A Comparative Study of Grinding Kinetics of Ceramic Balls and Steel Balls for Tungsten Ore in Ball Mills
袁程方,赖俊全,余超,黄伟生,谢加文,吴彩斌
摘要(Abstract):
本文以湖南柿竹园公司钨矿石为研究对象,计算其实验室批次瓷球和钢球磨矿产品动力学模型,与钢球进行比较并验证该预测模型的准确性。试验结果表明,瓷球磨矿与钢球磨矿相比,粒度较大颗粒(+0.15 mm)破碎速率明显低于钢球,对粗粒级钨矿石的破碎具有局限性;细粒级的零阶产出特征结果表明,瓷球磨矿已经改变了钨矿石碎裂特征,a值较钢球磨矿降低0.15,其破碎主要作用力由法向冲击力改为切向研磨力,可以有效避免贯穿破碎,降低次生细泥生成;钨矿石瓷球磨矿动力学特征趋向于一阶磨矿动力学模型,其模型方程式为R=R_0e~(-(0.027+11.85d~(1.93)))t分布,试验结果说明该模型对钨矿石的动力学模拟较为准确,可以用来预测各磨矿时间下磨矿产品的粒度特性。
关键词(KeyWords): 钨矿石;磨矿动力学;零阶产出特征;碎裂特征
基金项目(Foundation): 国家十四五重点研发计划子课题(2022YFC2905103)
作者(Author): 袁程方,赖俊全,余超,黄伟生,谢加文,吴彩斌
参考文献(References):
- [1]匡兵,余泽全.中国再生钨资源回收利用现状及建议[J].中国钨业,2021,36(4):1-5.KUANG Bing,YU Zequan.Current situation and suggestions on recycling and utilization of recycled tungsten resources in China[J].China Tungsten Industry,2021,36(4):1-5.
- [2]余泽全,苏刚.2020年中国钨工业发展报告[J].中国钨业,2021,36(2):1-9.YU Zequan,SU Gang.2020 China tungsten industry development report[J].China Tungsten Industry,2021,36(2):1-9.
- [3]陈克锋,郭江旭,谭孝飞,等.湖南郴州某白钨矿选矿试验研究[J].中国钨业,2021,36(3):24-30.CHEN Kefeng,GUO Jiangxu,TAN Xiaofei,et al.Experimental study on beneficiation of a scheelite mine in Chenzhou,Hunan[J].China Tungsten Industry,2021,36(3):24-30.
- [4]高亚龙,刘全军,董敬申,等.云南某白钨矿浮选试验研究[J].中国钨业,2021,36(3):31-35.GAO Yalong,LIU Quanjun,DONG Jingshen,et al.Experimental study on flotation of a scheelite mine in Yunnan[J].China Tungsten Industry,2021,36(3):31-35.
- [5]刘庭忠,吴师金.某低品位白钨矿浮选试验研究[J].中国钨业,2020,35(3):42-47.LIU Tingzhong,WU Shijin.Experimental study on flotation of a low-grade scheelite[J].China Tungsten Industry,2020,35(3):42-47.
- [6]李强,曾繁森,常永强,等.钨细泥选矿工艺应用现状[J].矿产综合利用,2021(1):32-38.LI Qiang,ZENG Fansen,CHANG Yongqiang,et al.Application status of tungsten fine mud mineral processing technology[J].Comprehensive Utilization of Minerals,2021(1):32-38.
- [7]袁长亮.江西某钨矿钨细泥选矿工艺优化及应用研究[J].中国钨业,2020,35(4):33-37.YUAN Changliang.Research on beneficiation process optimization and application of tungsten fine mud from a tungsten mine in Jiangxi[J].China Tungsten Industry,2020,35(4):33-37.
- [8]徐敬吟.某低品位黑钨细泥尾矿回收试验研究[J].中国钨业,2018,33(3):33-36,66.XU Jingyin.Experimental study on the recovery of a low-grade wolframite fine mud tailings[J].China Tungsten Industry,2018,33(3):33-36,66.
- [9]王婷霞,李健民,刘坤,等.浮选-磁选-重选联合工艺分选某风化型黑白钨细泥研究[J].矿产保护与利用,2021,41(5):38-42.WANG Tingxia,LI Jianmin,LIU Kun,et al.Research on the separation of a weathered black and white tungsten fine mud by the combined process of flotation-magnetic separation-gravity separation[J].Mineral Protection and Utilization,2021,41(5):38-42.
- [10]刘安平,吴彩斌,严刘学,等.梅山铁矿精确化磨矿工业试验研究[J].矿冶工程,2014,34(5):58-61.LIU Anping,WU Caibin,YAN Liuxue,et al.Industrial test research on precision grinding of Meishan iron mine[J].Mining and Metallurgy Engineering,2014,34(5):58-61.
- [11]吴彩斌,周意超,程长敏,等.不同接触方式磨矿介质的钨矿磨矿动力学分析[J].有色金属工程,2016,6(4):58-62.WU Caibin,ZHOU Yichao,CHENG Changmin,et al.Kinetic analysis of tungsten ore grinding with different contact grinding media[J].Nonferrous Metals Engineering,2016,6(4):58-62.
- [12]FANG Xin,WU Caibin,LIAONingning,et al.The first attempt of applying ceramic balls in industrial tumbling mill:A case study[J].Minerals Engineering,2022,180,107504.
- [13]FANG Xin,WU Caibing,YUAN Chenfang,et al.Can ceramic balls and steel balls be combined in an industrial tumbling mill[J].Powder Technology,2022,412,118020.
- [14]ZHANG Xiaolong,QIN Yonghong,JIN Jianping,et al.High-efficiency and energy-co-servation grinding technology using a special ceramic-medium stirred mill:A pilot-scale study[J].Powder Technology,2022,396,354-365.
- [15]ZHANG Xiaolong,HANY Yuexin,GAO Peng,et al.Effects of grinding media on grinding products and flotation performance of chalcopyrite[J].Minerals Engineering,2020,145,106070.
- [16]徐今冬.瓷球对磁铁矿/石英二元矿物体系的交互影响研究[D].赣州:江西理工大学,2022.XU Jindong.Study on the interaction of ceramic balls on the magnetite/quartz binary mineral system[D].Ganzhou:Jiangxi University of Science and Technology,2022.
- [17]赖俊全,向子祥,李雨晴,等.纳米瓷球作细磨介质下的磨矿动力学[J].有色金属科学与工程,2021,12(3):100-105.LAI Junquan,XIANG Zixiang,LI Yuqing,et al.Grinding kinetics of nano-ceramic balls as fine grinding medium[J].Nonferrous Metal Science and Engineering,2021,12(3):100-105.
- [18]吴志强,方鑫,童佳琪,等.纳米瓷球作细磨介质下的磨矿能耗与粒度分布特征[J].有色金属科学与工程,2019,10(5):91-96.WU Zhiqiang,FANG Xin,TONG Jiaqi,et al.Grinding energy consumption and particle size distribution characteristics of nano-ceramic balls as fine grinding medium[J].Nonferrous Metal Science and Engineering,2019,10(5):91-96.
- [19]田鹏程,王泽红,毛勇.磨矿动力学研究现状及应用[J].中国矿业,2022,31(7):112-121.TIAN Pengcheng,WANG Zehong,MAO Yong.Research status and application of grinding dynamics[J].China Mining Industry,2022,31(7):112-121.
- [20]杨金林,周文涛,蒋林伶,等.磨矿动力学研究概述[J].矿产综合利用,2017(4):4-10.YANG Jinlin,ZHOU Wentao,JIANG Linling,et al.An overview of grinding dynamics research[J].Comprehensive Utilization of Minerals,2017(4):4-10.
- [21]侯英,印万忠,朱巨建,等.不同碎磨方式下紫金山金铜矿石的磨矿动力学行为[J].中南大学学报(自然科学版),2017,48(5):1127-1133.HOU Ying,YIN Wanzhong,ZHU Jujian,et al.Grinding dynamics behavior of Zijinshan gold-copper ore under different grinding methods[J].Journal of Central South University(Natural Science Edition),2017,48(5):1127-1133.
- [22]鄢发明,艾光华,吴彩斌,等.钨矿石磨矿动力学研究[J].有色金属科学与工程,2015,6(4):81-85,120.YAN Fafang,AI Guanghua,WU Caibin,et al.Research on the grinding kinetics of tungsten ore[J].Nonferrous Metal Science and Engineering,2015,6(4):81-85,120.